admin
The digital transformation of the restaurant industry, significantly accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has presented independent eateries with both unprecedented opportunities and substantial challenges. Among the most pressing issues for many establishments is the intricate relationship with third-party food delivery applications. While these platforms initially offered a lifeline during lockdowns, their high commission fees, lack of data transparency, and often inconsistent service quality have prompted a growing movement among restaurateurs to reclaim control over their online sales channels and customer relationships. Two prominent examples of this strategic shift come from Slice Pizzeria in Utica, New York, and Woody’s Wood Fired Pizza in Golden, Colorado, each employing distinct but equally determined approaches to navigate this evolving landscape.
The Ascent of Delivery Giants and the Pandemic’s Crucible
Before the pandemic, third-party delivery services like DoorDash, Uber Eats, and Grubhub were already reshaping consumer dining habits, offering unparalleled convenience. However, their market penetration and indispensability skyrocketed in early 2020 as dining rooms shuttered and takeout became the sole option for many restaurants. For small businesses, particularly those without robust in-house delivery infrastructure, these platforms offered immediate access to a vast customer base, proving crucial for survival. The global online food delivery market, valued at approximately $150 billion in 2020, saw unprecedented growth, with some regions experiencing a 20-30% year-over-year increase in market size. This rapid expansion, while beneficial for visibility, came with a significant cost.
The standard business model for these third-party aggregators typically involves commission rates ranging from 15% to 30% or even higher per order. For an industry where profit margins often hover between 3% and 5%, these commissions represent a substantial drain, frequently pushing restaurants into unprofitable territory on delivery orders. Furthermore, many platforms initially onboarded restaurants without explicit consent, listing menus and often marking up prices to cover their fees, leading to confusion and frustration for both businesses and consumers.
Joe Rosemyer, who took ownership of Slice Pizzeria in 2019, experienced this dynamic firsthand. The same year, a major food delivery app automatically added his pizzeria’s menu to its platform. After an initial three-month period of free visibility, the delivery business presented Slice Pizzeria with an ultimatum: pay 30% of sales to remain visible to potential customers. Rosemyer recalls being an early adopter in the Utica area as the pandemic began to take hold, acknowledging that the app "exponentially helped business" during a critical period when patrons shifted en masse to takeout and delivery. However, the financial implications were profound, alongside a deeper concern: the apps retained crucial customer data.
The Data Dilemma: A Battle for Customer Insights
Beyond the immediate financial impact of high commissions, the loss of direct customer data emerged as a significant strategic concern for restaurateurs. Rosemyer articulated this dilemma succinctly: "They’re learning when the customer orders, how they order, how much they order – all those things that you should understand about your customer." This proprietary information, including ordering frequency, preferred items, average spend, and peak ordering times, is invaluable for targeted marketing, menu optimization, and fostering customer loyalty. When third-party apps control this data, restaurants lose the ability to directly engage with their clientele, tailor promotions, or build lasting relationships, effectively turning their customers into the app’s customers. This creates a dependency that can be leveraged by the delivery platforms, as Rosemyer noted, allowing them to dictate terms.
Recognizing the strategic importance of this data and the unsustainable nature of a 30% commission, Rosemyer embarked on a proactive strategy. As a "pretty high-volume pizzeria," Slice Pizzeria had leverage. He successfully negotiated a flat monthly fee with a delivery service, which was then integrated as an administrator into Slice Pizzeria’s existing online-ordering platform. This allowed the pizzeria to maintain a presence on the delivery network but under significantly more favorable financial terms and, crucially, with greater control over the ordering process and customer interaction. Rosemyer communicated this shift directly to his customers, encouraging them to order through the integrated system. This move translated into substantial savings, equivalent to "tens of thousands of dollars a year that went directly back into the business," a critical injection of capital for an independent establishment.
Woody’s Wood Fired Pizza: Pioneering Independence
While Slice Pizzeria pursued a negotiated coexistence, Woody’s Wood Fired Pizza in Golden, Colorado, chose a path of complete independence. Owner Jon Bortles had, serendipitously, laid the groundwork for this shift even before the pandemic hit. Operating out of a historic building that limited physical expansion, Bortles had invested in 2019 in converting a shipping container into a dedicated takeout and delivery kitchen, complete with a walk-up window, rooftop garden, and solar panels. This foresight proved invaluable when the pandemic forced a 100% switch to off-premise sales.
Bortles initially welcomed the support of third-party delivery partnerships, acknowledging that Woody’s was "fortunate enough to have already implemented online ordering and some of these third-party partnerships for delivery" when the crisis struck. However, the "shine dulled" quickly as issues with service quality began to erode customer satisfaction and the pizzeria’s reputation. Complaints ranged from drivers arriving without hot bags, leading to cold pizzas, to orders arriving an hour late. Despite Bortles’ efforts to address these concerns with the delivery companies, often securing refunds, the fundamental problem of unhappy customers persisted.
The constant need to mediate these issues became a significant operational burden. Bortles described it as "a full-time job, and quite honestly a distraction for the management team to constantly be dealing with issues… It just became a logistical nightmare." The core mission of Woody’s – delivering a high-quality product – was being jeopardized by factors outside their direct control. After experimenting with various apps and finding no sustainable solution, Woody’s made the decisive choice to "abandon that sales channel altogether." This bold move meant "completely got rid of all the third parties and do local delivery with our drivers here in town." While Bortles admits that delivery sales have decreased as a direct result, he firmly believes the trade-off is worth it for the improved food quality and brand integrity, achieved by limiting delivery distance and managing driver workloads.
Launching an In-House Fleet: A Strategic Investment
The decision by Woody’s to "cut the cord" necessitated building its own delivery infrastructure, a significant undertaking that many restaurants shy away from due to perceived complexities and costs. Bortles’ experience offers a practical blueprint for others considering a similar move.
The first critical step involved insurance. Woody’s discovered that its existing insurance policy did not exclude delivery, and their broker confirmed it was safe to proceed. This highlights the importance of thorough review and consultation with insurance providers.
Next came the challenge of staffing. Initially, Woody’s cross-trained existing servers and bussers to double as delivery drivers, leveraging their existing staff during the transition. Over time, as the in-house delivery model solidified, Bortles began hiring drivers specifically for the role. He emphasizes that success, like any aspect of the pizza business, "comes down to hiring the right people and training the right people." This involves rigorous processes, including background checks and motor vehicle inspections, to ensure safety and reliability.
Woody’s drivers are tipped employees who also earn an hourly wage, providing a stable income model. Crucially, drivers are required to maintain their own auto insurance. Bortles views this as "another layer of accountability, protection for our insurance company," ensuring both the driver and the business are adequately covered.
Optimizing operations was also key. After initially staffing drivers from 11 a.m. to 11 p.m., Woody’s management refined the schedule to focus on the busiest period: 4 p.m. to 8 p.m. During non-delivery times within their shift, drivers contribute to general takeout operations, answer phones, assist with prep work, or fill boxes, ensuring their time is always utilized productively. When an order comes in, they are dispatched directly from the kitchen, maintaining tight control over the delivery process.
Safety remains a paramount concern, particularly during Colorado’s challenging winters. Bortles has been known to suspend delivery operations entirely on nights with icy and hazardous road conditions. In anticipation of inclement weather, Woody’s actively promotes take-and-bake pizzas, allowing customers to enjoy their product without risking driver safety. "That way, nobody has to go out when the weather is bad… It’s just not worth it," Bortles asserts, underscoring a commitment to employee well-being that often contrasts with the pressure-cooker environment of third-party delivery.
Promoting Direct Orders and Cultivating Loyalty
Both Slice Pizzeria and Woody’s Wood Fired Pizza have implemented robust strategies to redirect customers from third-party apps to their direct ordering platforms, recognizing that true market share lies in direct customer engagement.
Woody’s leveraged a multi-channel marketing approach during its transition away from third-party apps. This included email campaigns, social media announcements, and in-store signage, all designed to inform customers about the change and encourage direct ordering. They temporarily offered a promotional period of free delivery to ease the transition and incentivize new habits. Today, delivery consumers pay a $4.99 delivery fee, which helps to reimburse drivers for gas and operational costs, a transparent approach that customers generally understand and accept for quality service.
A cornerstone of Woody’s strategy is its loyalty program. Patrons earn 25 points just for joining and one point for every dollar spent. Once a customer accrues 100 points (spending $100), they receive a $10 credit for their next order. This system is seamlessly integrated with their online ordering, notifying customers of their point balance and reward eligibility. Loyalty club members also receive exclusive benefits such as birthday discounts and special promotions, fostering a sense of appreciation and encouraging repeat business.
Joe Rosemyer of Slice Pizzeria, while maintaining a presence on some third-party apps, consistently drives customers to his website. "It’s branded on my boxes, and it’s on every social media post," he explains. "I’m constantly telling people about the website and the advantages. Any advertising I’m doing is all about the website." This consistent messaging reinforces the direct ordering channel as the preferred method. Slice Pizzeria also highlights unique benefits of direct orders, such as order tracking from start to finish and the assurance of one driver per order, minimizing potential delays or mishandling. They, too, offer a loyalty program, managed by their online delivery partner, which also handles targeted marketing emails based on the customer data they now control.
An unexpected, yet significant, benefit of the shift to online direct ordering, according to Rosemyer, is catering to evolving customer preferences. "People don’t want to talk on the phone," he notes, pointing out the social comfort of ordering online, especially for less conventional requests. "You might be embarrassed to order anchovies. People clown you for ordering pineapple." This insight underscores how direct online platforms can enhance the customer experience by removing potential social anxieties associated with phone orders, leading to greater freedom in customization and ordering frequency.
Broader Industry Implications and the Path Forward
The experiences of Slice Pizzeria and Woody’s Wood Fired Pizza reflect a broader trend within the restaurant industry. The initial dependence on third-party delivery apps has matured into a more strategic and often combative relationship. During the pandemic, many municipalities and states implemented temporary commission caps on third-party delivery services, typically limiting them to 15-20%, a clear acknowledgment of the financial strain these platforms imposed on local businesses. While many of these caps have since expired, they highlighted the public and governmental awareness of the issue.
The "win back" movement signifies a crucial reassertion of control by independent restaurants. It emphasizes the importance of direct customer relationships, data ownership, and brand integrity. Hybrid models, where restaurants selectively use third-party apps for broader visibility while actively promoting direct ordering, are becoming common. Others, like Woody’s, are opting for complete disengagement to ensure consistent quality and profitability.
For consumers, this shift means a greater awareness of how their ordering choices impact local businesses. While the convenience of a single app remains a draw, a growing number of patrons are choosing to support their favorite eateries directly, understanding that it often means more of their money goes directly to the restaurant, potentially leading to better service and product quality.
The strategies employed by these pizzerias offer valuable lessons for the wider food service industry. They underscore the need for adaptability, technological investment, and a clear understanding of one’s business model. In an increasingly digital marketplace, reclaiming market share from intermediaries is not just about cost savings; it’s about preserving brand identity, fostering customer loyalty, and ensuring the long-term viability of independent restaurants. The battle for the digital plate continues, with innovative restaurateurs leading the charge to redefine the terms of engagement.
