The stark reality of a changing climate has forced a profound reckoning within America’s agricultural sector, driving farmers and advocacy groups to adapt, litigate, and fundamentally rethink their approaches to land stewardship and public discourse. One such farmer, Gillingham, offers a poignant illustration of this shift. Years ago, he abandoned low-land vegetable farming after a relentless series of what were once considered "hundred-year floods" devastated his operations within a remarkably short span. These catastrophic events didn’t just cause temporary setbacks; they eradicated 70 percent of his precious topsoil, destroyed three tractors, and rendered substantial equipment unusable. "It stopped making sense," he recalled, a sentiment echoing across countless farms grappling with unprecedented weather volatility.
Gillingham’s personal transformation mirrors a broader trend: a move towards resilience and adaptation. He now cultivates a small orchard and raises hardy Icelandic sheep and Scottish Highland cattle on a high ridge, strategically positioned well above the encroaching flood plains. Beyond his own farm, Gillingham has become a prominent voice for climate action within the agricultural community, underscoring the urgency felt by those on the front lines of environmental change.
The Legal Front: Farmers Take on Federal Agencies
The escalating impacts of climate change have compelled agricultural organizations to move beyond mere adaptation, entering the legal arena to demand governmental accountability and support for farmers. The Northeast Organic Farming Association of New York (NOFA-NY), for which Gillingham serves as an influential member, has emerged as a key player in this fight. Over the past two years, the organization has initiated two significant lawsuits against the Trump administration, highlighting critical deficiencies in federal climate policy and farmer access to vital information.
The first legal challenge targeted the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) for systematically scrubbing its official website of crucial climate change resources. These resources, meticulously compiled over years, provided farmers with data, research, and best practices for mitigating and adapting to climate impacts—everything from soil carbon sequestration techniques to water management strategies in drought-prone regions. NOFA-NY argued that by removing these pages, the USDA was not only undermining scientific consensus but also directly hindering farmers’ ability to make informed decisions essential for their livelihoods and national food security. The lawsuit asserted that access to such information was not merely beneficial but a fundamental need for a sector increasingly vulnerable to extreme weather events. The legal pressure proved effective; the agency ultimately settled, agreeing to reinstate the removed climate change resources. This victory, while significant, underscored the tenuous nature of federal support for climate action during that period.
A subsequent and equally critical legal action saw NOFA-NY joining a lawsuit against the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). This suit challenged the EPA’s controversial decision to roll back the "endangerment finding," a pivotal determination that greenhouse gases pose a threat to public health and welfare. The endangerment finding, established in 2009 under the Supreme Court’s Massachusetts v. EPA ruling, provided the legal bedrock for the EPA’s authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act. By dismantling this finding, the EPA effectively sought to cripple its own ability to address climate change, a move with profound implications for all sectors of the economy, including agriculture.
Gillingham articulated the rationale behind NOFA-NY’s involvement in this high-stakes litigation: "Farmers understand the ramifications of climate change and the immensity of change that needs to happen to protect rural communities better than anyone." This statement encapsulates a core belief that those who directly depend on the land for their sustenance and livelihood possess an intimate, visceral understanding of environmental shifts that often eludes policymakers in distant urban centers. The repeated assertion, "I’ve talked to farmers from around the country. They’re all trying to deal with climate change," reinforces the pervasive, undeniable nature of these challenges across diverse agricultural landscapes.
The Political Divide: Climate Talk at the Kitchen Table vs. Public Discourse
While the physical impacts of climate change are universally felt by farmers, the discourse surrounding it remains deeply fractured along political and cultural lines, particularly in rural America. In regions with more liberal political leanings, farmers have openly advocated for climate action, even participating in public demonstrations and marches in recent years. However, in more conservative areas, the language and framing of climate change become fraught with ideological tension.
Research conducted by Petersen-Rockney in California sheds light on this nuanced dynamic. She observed that while farmers frequently discussed the impacts of extreme weather events—unpredictable rainfall, prolonged droughts, sudden freezes—and might even refer to "climate change" in the informal setting of a kitchen table conversation, they often felt constrained from using such terminology in public forums within their communities. This reluctance stems from the deep-seated political conservatism prevalent in many rural areas, where climate change has become a litmus test of ideological allegiance.
"I don’t want to gloss over the great degree of diversity of beliefs and opinions and political thought in these rural places," Petersen-Rockney explained, "but on average, they are very politically conservative, and climate change is a sort of test of your conservative chops." This creates a challenging paradox: farmers are directly grappling with the severe consequences of a changing climate, yet they often feel unable to openly acknowledge or discuss the root cause due to social and political pressures.
A 2019 Pew Research Center survey underscored this profound partisan divide. When respondents were asked to assess the seriousness of various global threats, including North Korea’s nuclear program and ISIS, the starkest partisan gap emerged specifically around climate change. This data highlights that the issue is not merely a scientific debate but a deeply entrenched cultural and political flashpoint, making open dialogue and consensus-building incredibly difficult, especially in communities where political identity is strongly tied to conservative values.
Bridging the Gap: The Rise of Regenerative Agriculture and Co-Benefits
Recognizing the polarizing nature of the term "climate change," experts and advocates are increasingly advocating for a strategic shift in language and focus. Petersen-Rockney views the growing adoption of "regenerative" terminology as a significant step forward. This shift is particularly impactful because, with the emergence of movements like "Make America Healthy Again" (MAHA), regenerative farming practices have garnered unexpected support from across the political spectrum.
"With the rise of MAHA, regenerative agriculture has very quickly moved from a fringe-left kind of topic to a center-right topic," she observed. This ideological migration has created "a really interesting opening," primarily because the on-the-ground practices associated with regenerative agriculture, agroecology, and conservation are fundamentally the same, regardless of the political label applied. These practices include minimal soil disturbance (no-till), cover cropping, diverse crop rotations, integrated livestock, and reduced synthetic inputs—all of which improve soil health, enhance biodiversity, and increase farm resilience.
Instead of getting bogged down in terminology, Petersen-Rockney argues that the most effective path forward is to emphasize the tangible "co-benefits" of these farm practices. These benefits resonate with farmers across the political divide: lower costs for inputs (fertilizers, pesticides), reduced water usage, improved yields, and enhanced soil fertility. Crucially, these practices also happen to mitigate climate change by sequestering carbon in the soil and reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
"There are so many pros to adopting these practices," she asserted, suggesting that meeting people "where they’re at" and focusing on actionable solutions rather than ideological belief systems will yield greater progress. This pragmatic approach sidesteps the politically charged rhetoric surrounding climate change and instead highlights immediate, economic, and practical advantages for farmers.
The Soil & Climate Initiative: A Model for Pragmatic Engagement
This strategic approach is not merely theoretical; it is actively being implemented by organizations like the Soil & Climate Initiative. Hulse Dillon, involved with the initiative, confirmed that their work with farms transitioning to regenerative practices has long employed this tactic. "In conservative areas, we’ve never gone in there and talked about climate change. We’ve never used those words," she stated.
The effectiveness of this strategy was dramatically underscored in 2020 when a devastating Derecho—a widespread, long-lived, straight-line wind storm—swept across Iowa farms. While conventional farms suffered extensive damage, including widespread crop lodging and soil erosion, regenerative farms, characterized by healthier soils and stronger root systems from cover crops, often fared significantly better. This stark contrast provided a powerful, undeniable demonstration of the "resilience" conferred by regenerative practices.
Following this event, Hulse Dillon’s team began to explicitly emphasize resilience in their conversations with farmers. More recently, however, the primary focus has shifted to "cost savings." "Honestly, the last few years we’ve really been talking about cost savings. That’s been a huge thing," she noted. This emphasis on economic benefits, such as reduced need for costly synthetic fertilizers and herbicides, and improved water retention leading to lower irrigation costs, offers a compelling incentive that transcends political affiliations. For a farmer facing tightening margins, the promise of increased profitability and reduced risk is often more persuasive than abstract discussions about global warming.
Beyond the Farm Gate: The Broader Climate Conundrum
While the widespread adoption of climate-smart, regenerative agricultural practices represents a critical step forward, even if farmers embrace these methods without ever uttering the term "climate change," the agricultural sector cannot solve the climate crisis in isolation. The imperative remains to drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions across all sectors of the economy to avert catastrophic global outcomes.
Gillingham’s point about the EPA’s decision to roll back the endangerment finding serves as a stark reminder of this broader challenge. The ending of federal regulation of greenhouse gas emissions "does have a direct impact on us," he emphasized. No amount of careful phrasing or focus on co-benefits within agriculture can alter the reality that systemic, economy-wide policy is essential. Without robust regulatory frameworks addressing industrial emissions, energy production, transportation, and other major contributors to climate change, even the most resilient and regenerative farms will continue to face an escalating barrage of extreme weather events and ecological disruptions.
The journey of American agriculture through the climate crisis is multifaceted. It involves individual farmers like Gillingham adapting their operations, tenacious legal battles waged by advocacy groups like NOFA-NY, and strategic shifts in communication aimed at bridging deep political divides. The rise of regenerative agriculture, framed around tangible co-benefits and economic resilience, offers a promising pathway for on-the-ground action. However, the ultimate success in safeguarding rural communities and ensuring long-term food security will depend not only on the ingenuity and adaptability of farmers but also on comprehensive, science-based policy at the highest levels of government. The challenges are immense, but the agricultural community, often considered the most conservative sector, is increasingly demonstrating a pragmatic willingness to confront them head-on, even if the language used to describe the problem must evolve to meet people where they are.







