Decanter, a leading authority in the global wine industry, continues its highly anticipated countdown to the Top 10 US Wines of 2026, revealing the second set of selections, numbers 40 through 31. This esteemed list, meticulously curated by Decanter’s US-based reviewers over the past 12 months, showcases an unparalleled diversity and exceptional quality within the American wine landscape. Each featured wine has achieved a remarkable score of 95 points or higher, distinguishing itself not only through its sensory excellence but also through a compelling narrative that underscores its significance within its respective region or the broader industry.

The criteria for inclusion on this prestigious list extend beyond mere scores, emphasizing wines that set new precedents, introduce innovative approaches in established areas, represent a significant evolution within a winery’s portfolio, or highlight the peak performance of exceptional vineyards and winemakers. This segment of the countdown spotlights standout bottlings from Oregon, Washington, and California’s iconic Napa, Sonoma, and Mendocino counties, offering a blend of well-known names and exciting new discoveries for connoisseurs and enthusiasts alike. The ongoing release culminates on Friday, 20 November, with the unveiling of the Top 10. For those interested in the initial selections, wines 50 to 41 were previously published, providing a comprehensive overview of the list’s rigorous methodology and diverse scope.
The Elite Selections: Wines 40 to 31

This current tranche of wines paints a vivid picture of the dynamic and evolving American wine scene, demonstrating the depth of talent and terroir across the West Coast. From the rugged peaks of Washington’s Red Mountain to the cool, coastal valleys of Oregon and California, these wines embody innovation, tradition, and a relentless pursuit of quality.
Wine No. 40: Liminal, WeatherEye Vineyard Block 47 Cabernet Sauvignon, Red Mountain, Columbia Valley, Washington, USA 2023 (96 points)

Hailing from one of the Columbia Valley’s most dramatic and challenging sites, the Liminal WeatherEye Vineyard Block 47 Cabernet Sauvignon 2023 stands as a testament to extreme viticulture. WeatherEye Vineyard, perched atop Red Mountain, spans elevations from 950 feet to over 1,400 feet, well above the ancient floodline that sculpted the region’s landscape. Here, the vines contend with thin, rocky soils and relentless, harsh winds, conditions that demand meticulous vineyard management but ultimately yield fruit of extraordinary concentration and character.
The visionaries behind WeatherEye, owner Cam Myhrvold and vineyard manager Ryan Johnson, have pioneered a micro-block planting strategy, customizing layout, density, and vine-training techniques to suit the nuanced variations in exposure and soil composition across the property. While much of WeatherEye is renowned for its Syrah and other Rhône varieties thriving in this demanding environment, Block 47 offers a unique expression of Cabernet Sauvignon. This less than one-acre parcel is situated on the lower, southwest-facing slopes, benefiting from intense daytime sun exposure followed by substantial nocturnal temperature drops. This diurnal shift is crucial for preserving acidity, contributing to the wine’s remarkable balance of intensity and refinement.

The Liminal label itself is a collaborative venture between Avennia owners Chris Peterson, the winemaker, and Marty Taucher, dedicated exclusively to WeatherEye fruit. Peterson’s "Block Highlight Series" selectively showcases individual vineyard sections that achieve exceptional distinction in a given vintage. The 2023 Block 47 Cabernet Sauvignon, aged for nearly two years in 70% new French oak, reveals a classic profile of pomegranate, blackberry, violet, and exotic spices on the nose. The palate mirrors this complexity with smoky cloves, Moroccan Berbere spices, and crushed pencil lead framing intense dried figs and dark chocolate with mint. Its undeniable refinement through intensity makes it a benchmark for Washington Cabernet.
Wine No. 39: Beaux Frères, The Belles Sœurs Pinot Noir, Ribbon Ridge, Willamette Valley, Oregon, USA, 2024 (96 points)

The journey of Beaux Frères, from a former pig farm to one of Oregon’s most celebrated Pinot Noir estates, is a remarkable narrative of vision and dedication. Founded in 1988 by Michael G. Etzel, the winery, located in the Ribbon Ridge AVA, has long been a beacon for collectible Oregon Pinot Noir. Its continued streak of quality is particularly noteworthy under its new shared ownership with Artémis Domaines, a prestigious portfolio that includes Bordeaux’s Château Latour, Burgundy’s Clos de Tart, and Napa’s Eisele Vineyard. This partnership signifies a global endorsement of Beaux Frères’ pedigree and the Willamette Valley’s potential on the world stage.
Leadership has transitioned gracefully, with Damien Lapuyade now serving as winemaker, and Mikey (Michael D.) Etzel, who grew up on the property, taking on the roles of CEO and technical director, succeeding his father. The estate’s viticultural assets have expanded, with the original Beaux Frères and Upper Terrace vineyards now complemented by the Bridge Vineyard, a contiguous 8.9-hectare (22-acre) parcel acquired in 2021, integrated into the estate as of the 2023 harvest.

The Belles Sœurs Pinot Noir, an estate blend from selected parcels across these vineyards (17% Beaux Frères Vineyard, 83% Bridge Vineyard), is crafted using biodynamic practices, reflecting a deep commitment to environmental stewardship and terroir expression. Winemaking follows traditional methods, including native yeasts, 30% to 50% new oak barrels, long and slow secondary fermentations, and aging on the lees for up to a year before racking. The 2024 vintage, described by Mike D. Etzel as a "modern classic," marks a return to cooler, steadier growing conditions after a series of warmer seasons, allowing the wine to express the classic elegance, freshness, and sanguine character expected of Willamette Valley Pinot Noir. With fresh red fruit, rose petals, cedar, tobacco, and finely pixelated tannins, this phenomenal wine promises a long life in the cellar.
Wine No. 38: DeLille Cellars, Chaleur Estate, Yakima Valley, Columbia Valley, Washington, USA 2023 (96 points)

DeLille Cellars has, for over three decades, been a standard-bearer for Washington State wines, particularly through its sophisticated Bordeaux-style blends. The Chaleur Estate red, first introduced in 1992, remains a benchmark, celebrated for its ability to showcase the state’s strengths by masterfully blending varieties and vineyard sites. Its white counterpart, Chaleur Blanc, a barrel-fermented blend of Sauvignon Blanc and Semillon, also stands as one of Washington’s premier white wines.
While DeLille emphasizes fruit from the small, warm, dry, and windy Red Mountain AVA, the specific vineyard sources and blend percentages for Chaleur Estate are adapted annually to capture the best expression of each vintage. The 2023 bottling is a compelling composition of 66% Cabernet Sauvignon, 23% Merlot, and 9% Cabernet Franc, sourced from three of Washington’s most revered sites. Ciel du Cheval, a foundational Red Mountain vineyard, contributed Cabernet from a 1982 planting, offering venerable depth. Boushey Vineyard, located in a cooler sector of the broader Yakima Valley AVA, supplied Merlot from an older block, known for its structure and complexity. Champoux Vineyard, nestled in the Horse Heaven Hills, has a long-standing reputation as a source for many of Washington’s most acclaimed wines, including Quilceda Creek’s renowned Columbia Valley Cabernet.

The winemaking team, led by Jason Gorski (Vice President of Winemaking), along with winemaker Nick Bernstein and assistant winemaker Mari Rossi, meticulously crafted this wine. It undergoes nearly two years of aging almost entirely in new French oak, followed by 10 months of bottle maturation. The result is a silken and smooth wine with alluring notes of smoky spice, roast cinnamon, star anise, sweet blueberries, taut red berries, and savory herbals. At a release price of $90, the 2023 Chaleur Estate represents a relative bargain among top-tier Bordeaux blends from the West Coast, inviting a fresh look at the exceptional quality and value offered by Washington Cabernet.
Wine No. 37: Wentworth, Nash Mill Vineyard Pinot Noir, Anderson Valley, Mendocino County, California, USA 2024 (96 points)

Mark Wentworth’s journey into winemaking is deeply rooted in a lifelong connection to the forest, a passion that now manifests in his exceptional Pinot Noir and Chardonnay grown amidst the majestic redwoods of western Mendocino County. Beginning in 2014 with an undeveloped parcel, Wentworth, joined by his partner Katie, has meticulously assembled three prime properties, totaling 25 acres of vines, across the Mendocino Ridge and Anderson Valley AVAs. Their commitment to the land is evident in their consistent production of outstanding to exceptional wines, with the 2024 vintage being lauded as their best overall.
This particular Pinot Noir emerges from their Nash Mill Vineyard, established in 2000 within one of the coolest reaches of the Anderson Valley, approximately 12 miles from the bracing influence of the Pacific Ocean. Wentworth acquired this vineyard in 2017, immediately implementing a permanent cover crop and ceasing tillage, aligning with his overarching goal of building soil health through organic and regenerative farming practices.

Wentworth’s dedication extends beyond the vineyard boundaries. The site is strategically located near the confluence of two waterways, including Mill Creek, a vital spawning ground for salmon and trout. In a testament to his conservationist ethos, Wentworth has actively partnered with the Nature Conservancy and Trout Unlimited to facilitate the creek’s restoration. The winery also proudly contributes to 1% for the Planet, reinforcing its commitment to environmental causes. Surrounded by a rich tapestry of redwoods, Douglas firs, madrones, and pine trees, the tiny Nash Mill vineyard unmistakably imparts its unique Mendocino terroir into the glass. The 2024 Nash Mill Vineyard Pinot Noir, showcasing soaring forest notes, wild woodland berries, purple florals, and salty sea air, braced by fresh crushed cranberry and a wild mint finish, is a gorgeous expression of its cool-climate origins.
Wine No. 36: Benton-Lane, Cima Single Block Series Pinot Noir, Lower Long Tom, Willamette Valley, Oregon, USA, 2024 (96 points)

Benton-Lane holds a prominent position as one of the most respected names in the southern Willamette Valley, a region that, despite its quality, is often overlooked. Founder Steve Girard played a pivotal role in pioneering this area in the late 1980s and early 1990s, laying the groundwork for its recognition. The region’s distinctiveness was formally acknowledged with the approval of the Lower Long Tom AVA in late 2021, a testament to its unique terroir. Under the ownership of Huneeus Vintners, Benton-Lane has embarked on a new chapter, featuring a new winemaker, Amael Orrego, and a state-of-the-art winery.
Orrego has refined the winery’s focus, concentrating exclusively on estate wines: one Chardonnay and three Pinot Noirs, a strategic move to highlight the depth and nuance of their own vineyards. The team has invested considerable effort in comprehensive soil studies across its 140 acres of vineyards, some of which date back to 1991. This in-depth understanding of their land, coupled with the flexibility afforded by the new winemaking facility to ferment small lots individually, allows for unparalleled precision in crafting their wines.

The Cima Single Block Series Pinot Noir is a direct result of this focused approach, designed to express the estate’s micro-terroirs. "Cima," meaning "summit" in Spanish, aptly describes its origin from the highest slopes of the property, at an elevation of 800 feet (244 meters), characterized by deep volcanic soils over sandstone bedrock. While this site typically imbues the wine with dark-fruit intensity, the 2024 vintage, marked by early rainfall and moderate temperatures throughout the growing season, allowed for a harmonious expression of Oregon’s classic elegance and freshness.
Benton-Lane is also a leader in Oregon’s sustainable winegrowing movement. Its vineyards are dry-farmed and hold three significant sustainable farming certifications: LIVE, Salmon Safe, and Bee Friendly Farming, reflecting a holistic commitment to environmental health and biodiversity. The 2024 Cima Pinot Noir exhibits deep red and black fruits, a ferrous streak, and a sanguine character on the palate, with sturdy tannins and acid promising a long cellar life.

Wine No. 35: Avennia, Valery, Columbia Valley, Washington, USA 2023 (96 points)
Avennia represents the original and foundational project of winemaker Chris Peterson and investor Marty Taucher, the same formidable duo behind the Liminal label. While Liminal delves into the singular expression of WeatherEye Vineyard, Avennia crafts its acclaimed Bordeaux- and Rhône-style blends by drawing upon a diverse array of top-tier vineyards across Washington State. These esteemed sites include Red Willow and Boushey in the Yakima Valley, Sagemoor in the White Bluffs AVA, and Avennia’s own estate in Red Mountain, featuring Cabernet plantings dating back to the mid







